On semigroups which admit only discrete left-continuous Hausdorff topology
Oleg Gutik
TL;DR
The paper investigates when every Hausdorff left-continuous (or right-continuous) topology on a semigroup must be discrete, focusing on the bicyclic monoid ${\mathscr{C}}(a,b)$ and its extensions. It provides a general sufficient condition ensuring discreteness of such topologies and constructs continuum-many subsemigroups ${S_\alpha}$ inside ${\mathscr{C}}_{+}(a,b)$ and ${\mathscr{C}}_{-}(a,b)$ that simultaneously admit non-discrete topologies on the opposite side and embed into compact Hausdorff semigroups. It also extends these phenomena to subsemigroups of ${\mathscr{C}}^{+}_{\mathbb{Z}}$ and ${\mathscr{C}}^{-}_{\mathbb{Z}}$, with anti-isomorphic duals, and analyzes non-discrete shift-continuous topologies on the extended semigroup ${\mathscr{C}}_{\mathbb{Z}}$. Finally, the paper describes compactification constructions that place ${\mathscr{C}}_{\mathbb{Z}}^{+}$ (and analogues) densely inside compact topological semigroups, ensuring that every subsemigroup has a dense compactification, and discusses the broader landscape of shift-continuous locally compact topologies for these algebras.
Abstract
We give the sufficient condition when every left-continuous (right-continuous) Hausdorff topology on a semigroup $S$ is discrete. We construct a submonoid $\mathscr{C}_{+}(a,b)$ (resp., $\mathscr{C}_{-}(a,b)$) of the bicyclic monoid which contains a family $\{S_α\colon α\in\mathfrak{c}\}$ of continuum many subsemigroups with the following properties: $(i)$ every left-continuous (resp., right-continuous) Hausdorff topology on $S_α$ is discrete; $(ii)$ every semigroup $S_α$ admits a non-discrete right-continuous (resp., left-continuous) Hausdorff topology which is not left-continuous (resp., right-continuous); $(iii)$ every semigroup $S_α$ isomorphically embeds into a Hausdorff compact topological semigroup. Also we construct a submonoid $\mathscr{C}_{\mathbb{Z}}^+$ (resp., $\mathscr{C}_{\mathbb{Z}}^-$) of the extended bicyclic semigroup which contains a family $\{S_α\colon α\in\mathfrak{c}\}$ of continuum many subsemigroups with the above described properties.
