Is Nano Banana Pro a Low-Level Vision All-Rounder? A Comprehensive Evaluation on 14 Tasks and 40 Datasets
Jialong Zuo, Haoyou Deng, Hanyu Zhou, Jiaxin Zhu, Yicheng Zhang, Yiwei Zhang, Yongxin Yan, Kaixing Huang, Weisen Chen, Yongtai Deng, Rui Jin, Nong Sang, Changxin Gao
TL;DR
The paper probes whether a large-scale generative model, NB Pro, can serve as a zero-shot, low-level vision all-rounder. Across 14 tasks and 40 datasets, NB Pro delivers high perceptual quality and coherentSemantic reconstructions but consistently falls short of domain-specific methods on pixel-accurate restoration metrics like PSNR/SSIM. The study reveals a fundamental perceptual-fidelity dichotomy: generative priors enable impressive visual results and cross-task generalization, yet they introduce semantic shifts and texture hallucinations that degrade fidelity-based evaluations. It argues for new evaluation frameworks and hybrid approaches that couple NB Pro’s semantic strengths with physics-informed constraints to achieve reliable, high-fidelity restoration. Overall, NB Pro highlights the potential and the current limits of unified generative models in low-level vision, advocating a blended future where perceptual quality and pixel accuracy are jointly optimized.
Abstract
The rapid evolution of text-to-image generation models has revolutionized visual content creation. While commercial products like Nano Banana Pro have garnered significant attention, their potential as generalist solvers for traditional low-level vision challenges remains largely underexplored. In this study, we investigate the critical question: Is Nano Banana Pro a Low-Level Vision All-Rounder? We conducted a comprehensive zero-shot evaluation across 14 distinct low-level tasks spanning 40 diverse datasets. By utilizing simple textual prompts without fine-tuning, we benchmarked Nano Banana Pro against state-of-the-art specialist models. Our extensive analysis reveals a distinct performance dichotomy: while \textbf{Nano Banana Pro demonstrates superior subjective visual quality}, often hallucinating plausible high-frequency details that surpass specialist models, it lags behind in traditional reference-based quantitative metrics. We attribute this discrepancy to the inherent stochasticity of generative models, which struggle to maintain the strict pixel-level consistency required by conventional metrics. This report identifies Nano Banana Pro as a capable zero-shot contender for low-level vision tasks, while highlighting that achieving the high fidelity of domain specialists remains a significant hurdle.
