Table of Contents
Fetching ...

Tracking optical variability and outflows across the accretion states of the black hole transient MAXI J1820+070

M. C. Baglio, K. Alabarta, D. M. Russell, N. Masetti, M. M. Messa, T. Muñoz Darias, F. M. Vincentelli, S. K. Rout, P. Saikia, A. Gabuya, V. Chavushyan, T. Al Qaissieh, A. Palado

TL;DR

This paper presents a comprehensive, multi-wavelength study of MAXI J1820+070 during its 2018 outburst and subsequent reflares, focusing on minute-timescale optical variability and optical wind signatures. By combining high-cadence optical photometry from LCO and Al Sadeem with simple X-ray hardness diagnostics and low-resolution spectroscopy, the authors test the internal shock jet model as the primary driver of rapid optical variability in the hard state, while showing jet quenching and disc-dominated variability in the soft state. The results show a clear rms–hardness correlation, wavelength dependence favoring jet-dominated synchrotron emission, and wind signatures in hard states that are suppressed in soft states, reinforcing an accretion–ejection coupling in BH-LMXBs and extending jet variability signatures to optical wavelengths. Taken together, the findings constrain the jet–wind interplay and highlight residual cyclo-synchrotron emission as a potential contributor in the faint hard states.

Abstract

We present a study of the minute-timescale optical variability and spectroscopic outflow signatures in the black hole X-ray binary MAXI J1820+070 during its 2018 outburst and re-brightenings. Minute-cadence, multi-filter optical light curves were obtained with the Las Cumbres Observatory network and the Al Sadeem Observatory (UAE) over 2018-2020, complemented by X-ray data from Swift/BAT, XRT, and MAXI. We also acquired contemporaneous low-resolution optical spectra with the 2.1 m OAN San Pedro Martir and OAGH Cananea telescopes (Mexico) and the 1.5 m G.D. Cassini telescope at Loiano (Italy). The optical fractional rms peaks in the hard state and is dominated by short-timescale flickering that strengthens toward longer wavelengths, suggesting that the variability is jet-driven. In this scenario, inflow fluctuations inject velocity perturbations at the jet base (internal shock model). The variability is quenched in the soft state, with any residual signal likely linked to accretion-flow fluctuations. This behaviour supports the accretion-ejection coupling in black hole binaries and shows that the jet's variability signature extends to optical wavelengths in all hard states. In the faintest hard states, residual optical variability may instead trace cyclo-synchrotron emission from the hot flow. The spectra show double-peaked emission lines and tentative cold-wind signatures during the hard state. Such winds were reported during the main 2018 outburst; here we find evidence of their presence also in later re-brightenings. Their absence in the soft state likely reflects stronger disc ionisation from the higher X-ray flux, suppressing low-ionisation optical features.

Tracking optical variability and outflows across the accretion states of the black hole transient MAXI J1820+070

TL;DR

This paper presents a comprehensive, multi-wavelength study of MAXI J1820+070 during its 2018 outburst and subsequent reflares, focusing on minute-timescale optical variability and optical wind signatures. By combining high-cadence optical photometry from LCO and Al Sadeem with simple X-ray hardness diagnostics and low-resolution spectroscopy, the authors test the internal shock jet model as the primary driver of rapid optical variability in the hard state, while showing jet quenching and disc-dominated variability in the soft state. The results show a clear rms–hardness correlation, wavelength dependence favoring jet-dominated synchrotron emission, and wind signatures in hard states that are suppressed in soft states, reinforcing an accretion–ejection coupling in BH-LMXBs and extending jet variability signatures to optical wavelengths. Taken together, the findings constrain the jet–wind interplay and highlight residual cyclo-synchrotron emission as a potential contributor in the faint hard states.

Abstract

We present a study of the minute-timescale optical variability and spectroscopic outflow signatures in the black hole X-ray binary MAXI J1820+070 during its 2018 outburst and re-brightenings. Minute-cadence, multi-filter optical light curves were obtained with the Las Cumbres Observatory network and the Al Sadeem Observatory (UAE) over 2018-2020, complemented by X-ray data from Swift/BAT, XRT, and MAXI. We also acquired contemporaneous low-resolution optical spectra with the 2.1 m OAN San Pedro Martir and OAGH Cananea telescopes (Mexico) and the 1.5 m G.D. Cassini telescope at Loiano (Italy). The optical fractional rms peaks in the hard state and is dominated by short-timescale flickering that strengthens toward longer wavelengths, suggesting that the variability is jet-driven. In this scenario, inflow fluctuations inject velocity perturbations at the jet base (internal shock model). The variability is quenched in the soft state, with any residual signal likely linked to accretion-flow fluctuations. This behaviour supports the accretion-ejection coupling in black hole binaries and shows that the jet's variability signature extends to optical wavelengths in all hard states. In the faintest hard states, residual optical variability may instead trace cyclo-synchrotron emission from the hot flow. The spectra show double-peaked emission lines and tentative cold-wind signatures during the hard state. Such winds were reported during the main 2018 outburst; here we find evidence of their presence also in later re-brightenings. Their absence in the soft state likely reflects stronger disc ionisation from the higher X-ray flux, suppressing low-ionisation optical features.
Paper Structure (22 sections, 2 equations, 13 figures, 5 tables)

This paper contains 22 sections, 2 equations, 13 figures, 5 tables.

Figures (13)

  • Figure 1: First panel: Optical LCO ($g'$ and $i'$) and Al Sadeem ($g'$, $V$, $R$) light curves of MAXI J1820+070 during its 2018/2019 outburst. Magnitudes are not corrected for reddening. Second panel: Swift/BAT (purple), Swift/XRT (pink) and MAXI/GSC (dark purple) count rates vs. MJD. Swift/BAT counts have been divided by 100 for graphic purpose. Third panel: MJD vs. fractional root mean square (rms) variability amplitude evaluated for the time-resoved optical light curves obtained with the LCO and Al Sadeem observations.Fourth panel: MJD vs. Hardness ratio evaluated as BAT/MAXI count rates ($\rm HR_{\rm BAT/MAXI}$) and XRT (2-10 keV)/XRT (0.5-2 keV) count rates ($\rm HR_{\rm XRT}$).
  • Figure 2: Hardness ratio (calculated as BAT/MAXI) vs. fractional rms of the optical LCO $g'$ (green dots) and $i'$ (black dots) data. Linear fits to the data are also represented with dashed green and black lines, respectively, to show the increasing trend of the fractional rms with the hardness.
  • Figure 3: Fractional rms vs. Hardness ratio calculated as the XRT 2-10 keV / XRT 0.5-2 keV flux and the optical fluxes obtained with LCO in the $i'$ (black) and $g'$ (green) bands. Broken power law fits are also represented with black and green dashed lines, respectively, to show the increasing trend of the fractional rms with a hardness >0.35. Results of the fits are reported in Tab. \ref{['tab:correlations_XRT']}.
  • Figure 4: Fractional rms of the optical LCO $g'$ (green dots) and $i'$ (black dots) data vs the Swift/XRT fractional rms amplitude (%) in the 2.0$-$10.0 keV energy band. The first three panels show the Swift/XRT rms obtained from 5s-, 20s- and 60s-binned light curves, respectively. The rightmost panel shows the Swift/XRT broadband-frequency rms 0.01$-$64 Hz (i.e. 0.02-100s) in the x-axis. Horizontal and vertical error bars represent one-sigma uncertainties calculated analytically for each respective method.
  • Figure 5: Absolute rms evaluated for LCO $i'$ and $g'$ band observations vs. Hardness of the X-ray spectrum, evaluated using the two Swift/XRT energy bands (2-10 for hard; 0.5-2 for soft).
  • ...and 8 more figures