Table of Contents
Fetching ...

Embedding-Aware Noise Modeling of Quantum Annealing

Seon-Geun Jeong, Mai Dinh Cong, Dae-Il Noh, Quoc-Viet Pham, Won-Joo Hwang

TL;DR

This work tackles the scalability challenges of quantum annealing arising from embedding overhead in sparse hardware by introducing an embedding-aware noise model that extends the integrated control error framework with Gaussian chain-level errors. It derives closed-form scaling relations for chain-break probability and chain-break fraction as functions of embedding size and validates them through experiments on D-Wave's Zephyr topology, demonstrating a practical design rule that chain strength should grow roughly as $\sqrt{\ell_i}$ to preserve reliability. The results reveal a sublinear but steeper-than-ideal scaling due to correlated hardware noise, prompting refinements to the model and highlighting embedding-aware calibration as essential for large-scale QA. The framework provides predictive tools for scalability assessment, guiding embedding-aware parameter tuning and hardware-conscious noise modeling toward more reliable quantum annealing on current devices.

Abstract

Quantum annealing provides a practical realization of adiabatic quantum computation and has emerged as a promising approach for solving large-scale combinatorial optimization problems. However, current devices remain constrained by sparse hardware connectivity, which requires embedding logical variables into chains of physical qubits. This embedding overhead limits scalability and reduces reliability as longer chains are more prone to noise-induced errors. In this work, building on the known structural result that the average chain length in clique embeddings grows linearly with the problem size, we develop a mathematical framework that connects embedding-induced overhead with hardware noise in D-Wave's Zephyr topology. Our analysis derives closed-form expressions for chain break probability and chain break fraction under a Gaussian control error model, establishing how noise scales with embedding size and how chain strength should be adjusted with chain length to maintain reliability. Experimental results from the Zephyr topology-based quantum processing unit confirm the accuracy of these predictions, demonstrating both the validity of the theoretical noise model and the practical relevance of the derived scaling rule. Beyond validating a theoretical model against hardware data, our findings establish a general embedding-aware noise framework that explains the trade-off between chain stability and logical coupler fidelity. Our framework advances the understanding of noise amplification in current devices and provides quantitative guidance for embedding-aware parameter tuning strategies.

Embedding-Aware Noise Modeling of Quantum Annealing

TL;DR

This work tackles the scalability challenges of quantum annealing arising from embedding overhead in sparse hardware by introducing an embedding-aware noise model that extends the integrated control error framework with Gaussian chain-level errors. It derives closed-form scaling relations for chain-break probability and chain-break fraction as functions of embedding size and validates them through experiments on D-Wave's Zephyr topology, demonstrating a practical design rule that chain strength should grow roughly as to preserve reliability. The results reveal a sublinear but steeper-than-ideal scaling due to correlated hardware noise, prompting refinements to the model and highlighting embedding-aware calibration as essential for large-scale QA. The framework provides predictive tools for scalability assessment, guiding embedding-aware parameter tuning and hardware-conscious noise modeling toward more reliable quantum annealing on current devices.

Abstract

Quantum annealing provides a practical realization of adiabatic quantum computation and has emerged as a promising approach for solving large-scale combinatorial optimization problems. However, current devices remain constrained by sparse hardware connectivity, which requires embedding logical variables into chains of physical qubits. This embedding overhead limits scalability and reduces reliability as longer chains are more prone to noise-induced errors. In this work, building on the known structural result that the average chain length in clique embeddings grows linearly with the problem size, we develop a mathematical framework that connects embedding-induced overhead with hardware noise in D-Wave's Zephyr topology. Our analysis derives closed-form expressions for chain break probability and chain break fraction under a Gaussian control error model, establishing how noise scales with embedding size and how chain strength should be adjusted with chain length to maintain reliability. Experimental results from the Zephyr topology-based quantum processing unit confirm the accuracy of these predictions, demonstrating both the validity of the theoretical noise model and the practical relevance of the derived scaling rule. Beyond validating a theoretical model against hardware data, our findings establish a general embedding-aware noise framework that explains the trade-off between chain stability and logical coupler fidelity. Our framework advances the understanding of noise amplification in current devices and provides quantitative guidance for embedding-aware parameter tuning strategies.

Paper Structure

This paper contains 25 sections, 5 theorems, 36 equations, 7 figures, 4 tables.

Key Result

Theorem 1

Under independent zero-mean Gaussian in Assumption Ass:NoiseModel, the variance of $\Delta(\ell_i)$ grows linearly with $\ell_i$:

Figures (7)

  • Figure 1: Illustration of Zephyr topology. (a) shows the actual hardware connectivity of the Advantage2_system1.6 QPU, while (b) shows a toy Zephyr graph $Z_{1,4}$ for clarity of unit-cell structure.
  • Figure 2: Average chain length as a function of logical problem size $L$ under clique embeddings on the D-Wave Advantage2_system1.6 QPU.
  • Figure 3: Observed mean CBF (blue) versus model-predicted CBF (orange) as a function of logical problem size $L$ under clique embeddings on the D-Wave Advantage2_system1.6 QPU. Results are shown for annealing time $T=5\,\mu$s and chain strength $k=1.0$.
  • Figure 4: Observed (blue bars) and model-predicted (orange hatched bars) mean CBF as a function of problem size $L$ under clique embeddings on the D-Wave Advantage2_system1.6 QPU. Each subfigures correspond to annealing times $T\in\{5,20,100,200\}\,\mu$s at fixed chain strength $k=1.5$.
  • Figure 5: Heatmap of observed mean CBF as a function of problem size $L$ and chain strength $k$ at fixed annealing time $T=20\,\mu$s.
  • ...and 2 more figures

Theorems & Definitions (15)

  • Definition 1: Minor Embedding and Chains
  • Definition 2: Embedded Hamiltonian grant2022benchmarking
  • Definition 3: Chain-Level Control Error
  • Theorem 1: Variance Scaling
  • proof
  • Definition 4: Chain Break Probability
  • Definition 5: Chain Break Fraction
  • Theorem 2: Gaussian Tail Approximation of CBP
  • proof
  • Lemma 1: Approximation of CBF by CBP
  • ...and 5 more