Table of Contents
Fetching ...

Language Models Guidance with Multi-Aspect-Cueing: A Case Study for Competitor Analysis

Amir Hadifar, Christopher Ochs, Arjan Van Ewijk

TL;DR

This paper tackles the gap that LLMs face in dynamic competitive landscapes by proposing Multi-Aspect Cueing (MAC), a prompt-level framework that injects business-related aspects into reasoning prompts. MAC decomposes the analysis into aspects, input values, and demonstrations, and uses Shapley Value Sampling to attribute outputs to each aspect; experiments show improved relevance scoring and memorization in telecom and other domains. Across three datasets (telecom InHouse, Recipe-MPR, FiQA SA), MAC outperforms baselines, with notable improvements on the InHouse dataset, where gains reach $>30\%$ at 5-shot and $>40\%$ at 10-shot. The results suggest that integrating domain-specific aspects into prompts enhances LLMs' ability to trade off criteria and recall relevant signals in shifting competitive landscapes, with practical benefits for competitor analysis workflows.

Abstract

Competitor analysis is essential in modern business due to the influence of industry rivals on strategic planning. It involves assessing multiple aspects and balancing trade-offs to make informed decisions. Recent Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated impressive capabilities to reason about such trade-offs but grapple with inherent limitations such as a lack of knowledge about contemporary or future realities and an incomplete understanding of a market's competitive landscape. In this paper, we address this gap by incorporating business aspects into LLMs to enhance their understanding of a competitive market. Through quantitative and qualitative experiments, we illustrate how integrating such aspects consistently improves model performance, thereby enhancing analytical efficacy in competitor analysis.

Language Models Guidance with Multi-Aspect-Cueing: A Case Study for Competitor Analysis

TL;DR

This paper tackles the gap that LLMs face in dynamic competitive landscapes by proposing Multi-Aspect Cueing (MAC), a prompt-level framework that injects business-related aspects into reasoning prompts. MAC decomposes the analysis into aspects, input values, and demonstrations, and uses Shapley Value Sampling to attribute outputs to each aspect; experiments show improved relevance scoring and memorization in telecom and other domains. Across three datasets (telecom InHouse, Recipe-MPR, FiQA SA), MAC outperforms baselines, with notable improvements on the InHouse dataset, where gains reach at 5-shot and at 10-shot. The results suggest that integrating domain-specific aspects into prompts enhances LLMs' ability to trade off criteria and recall relevant signals in shifting competitive landscapes, with practical benefits for competitor analysis workflows.

Abstract

Competitor analysis is essential in modern business due to the influence of industry rivals on strategic planning. It involves assessing multiple aspects and balancing trade-offs to make informed decisions. Recent Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated impressive capabilities to reason about such trade-offs but grapple with inherent limitations such as a lack of knowledge about contemporary or future realities and an incomplete understanding of a market's competitive landscape. In this paper, we address this gap by incorporating business aspects into LLMs to enhance their understanding of a competitive market. Through quantitative and qualitative experiments, we illustrate how integrating such aspects consistently improves model performance, thereby enhancing analytical efficacy in competitor analysis.

Paper Structure

This paper contains 14 sections, 6 figures, 5 tables.

Figures (6)

  • Figure 1: Multi-Aspect Cueing (MAC) example for competitor analysis. Highlighted words are aspects, and shaded are generated text by Llama2.
  • Figure 2: A visual example of aspect attributions using Shapely Value Sampling castro2009polynomial. Both aspects positively contribute to the predicted score.
  • Figure 3: LLM memorization for recognizing Telecommunication Service Provider (TSP) in headlines for the varying frequency levels with/without aspect-cueing.
  • Figure 4: A visual example of aspect contributions on LLM output for news excerpt: "XYZ Telecom to launch AI assistants for corporate clients", with specifying target attributes.
  • Figure 5: A visual example of aspect attributions for news excerpt: "Telecom giant, announces strategic partnership to accelerate the 5G Core", without specifying target aspects.
  • ...and 1 more figures