Logo
ScienceStack
Table of Contents
Fetching ...
Sign In

"Sighted People Have Their Pick Of The Litter": Unpacking The Need For Digital Mental Health (DMH) Tracking Services With And For The Blind Community

Omar Khan, JooYoung Seo

TL;DR

This study investigates the accessibility of digital mental health (DMH) tracking services for the blind community in the United States. Using a cross-sectional survey analyzed through Norman and Skinner's eHealth literacy framework, the authors identify critical barriers in navigation, content interpretation, and overall UX, as well as data privacy and financial constraints that hinder adoption. Mindfulness/meditation and sleep-tracking emerge as the most used DMH categories, but many participants report significant accessibility challenges and a need for adaptive, voice-guided interfaces and accessible data visualizations. The work provides design and policy recommendations aimed at creating inclusive DMH technologies, emphasizing proactive accessibility, data agency, and transparent privacy practices to promote digital equality in mental health care.

Abstract

The proliferation of digital mental health (DMH) tracking services promises personalized support, yet accessibility barriers limit equal access. This study investigates blind community experiences with DMH tracking services across the United States as a step toward inclusive health technology design. Working with blind advocacy organizations, we distributed a cross-sectional observational survey (n = 93) and analyzed open-ended responses using Norman and Skinner's eHealth Literacy framework. Our findings reveal significant challenges in navigation, content interpretation, and overall user experience, which impede the blind community's effective engagement with DMH tools. Results highlight the need for adaptive interfaces, accessible tracking strategies, and voice-guided interactions. These insights inform design recommendations for developers and policymakers, promoting more inclusive mental health technologies. By prioritizing accessibility, we make forward progress in ensuring that DMH tracking services fulfill their potential to support mental well-being across diverse user groups, fostering digital equality in mental health care.

"Sighted People Have Their Pick Of The Litter": Unpacking The Need For Digital Mental Health (DMH) Tracking Services With And For The Blind Community

TL;DR

This study investigates the accessibility of digital mental health (DMH) tracking services for the blind community in the United States. Using a cross-sectional survey analyzed through Norman and Skinner's eHealth literacy framework, the authors identify critical barriers in navigation, content interpretation, and overall UX, as well as data privacy and financial constraints that hinder adoption. Mindfulness/meditation and sleep-tracking emerge as the most used DMH categories, but many participants report significant accessibility challenges and a need for adaptive, voice-guided interfaces and accessible data visualizations. The work provides design and policy recommendations aimed at creating inclusive DMH technologies, emphasizing proactive accessibility, data agency, and transparent privacy practices to promote digital equality in mental health care.

Abstract

The proliferation of digital mental health (DMH) tracking services promises personalized support, yet accessibility barriers limit equal access. This study investigates blind community experiences with DMH tracking services across the United States as a step toward inclusive health technology design. Working with blind advocacy organizations, we distributed a cross-sectional observational survey (n = 93) and analyzed open-ended responses using Norman and Skinner's eHealth Literacy framework. Our findings reveal significant challenges in navigation, content interpretation, and overall user experience, which impede the blind community's effective engagement with DMH tools. Results highlight the need for adaptive interfaces, accessible tracking strategies, and voice-guided interactions. These insights inform design recommendations for developers and policymakers, promoting more inclusive mental health technologies. By prioritizing accessibility, we make forward progress in ensuring that DMH tracking services fulfill their potential to support mental well-being across diverse user groups, fostering digital equality in mental health care.

Paper Structure

This paper contains 18 sections, 5 figures, 1 table.

Table of Contents

  1. Introduction
  2. Related Work
  3. Mental Health Research in Human-Computer Interaction
  4. DMH Tracking Services And The Blind Community
  5. Methods
  6. Research Team
  7. Study Design
  8. Participant Recruitment
  9. Survey Analysis
  10. Findings and Discussion
  11. The Need For DMH Services Across The Blind Community
  12. Factors Influencing DMH Adoption Across the Blind Community
  13. The Blind Community's Data Agency Preferences with DMH Tracking Services
  14. Limitations
  15. Conclusion
  16. ...and 3 more sections

Figures (5)

  • Figure 1: Flow diagram displaying the survey's flow. Participants received varying questions depending on their response to the survey's "DMH Usage" portion. Upon completing the DMH-related questions, all participants had the chance to complete the same demographic and interview request questions.
  • Figure 2: Participants' reported experience levels with DMH tracking services (n=93).
  • Figure 3: Heatmap illustrating the relationship between DMH tracking service usage frequency and reasons for use across the blind community.
  • Figure 4: Participant ratings for DMH tracking services helpfulness and accessibility.
  • Figure 5: Participants' specific usability challenges and requirements for DMH tracking services.