A freeness criterion for complexes with derived actions
Sylvain Brochard, Srikanth B. Iyengar, Chandrashekhar B. Khare
TL;DR
This work develops a freeness criterion for the zeroth homology of finite free complexes with derived actions over local rings, seeking to avoid full patching. It identifies a precise defect bound $p=\operatorname{edim}A-\operatorname{edim}B$ that governs freeness and provides several cases where $\operatorname{H}_0(F)$ is free: (i) the regular case under derived-action bounds, (ii) the case where $F$ is a complex of $B$-modules with finite flat dimension, and (iii) the complete intersection case yielding detailed Betti-number relations and a Koszul-model conclusion. It also discusses consequences for patching in number theory, showing that derived-action freeness can obstruct strengthening patching data and lifting Hecke actions, while highlighting favorable outcomes when $B/\mathfrak{m}_A B$ is a complete intersection. Overall, the results support the plausibility of a non-patching freeness criterion and clarify the interplay between derived actions, depth, dimension, and complete intersection structure in various regimes.
Abstract
Inspired by the patching method of Calegari and Geraghty, and a conjecture of de Smit that has been proved by the first author, we present a conjectural freeness criterion without patching for complexes over commutative noetherian local rings with derived actions, and verify it in several cases.
