Square Functions Controlling Smoothness and Higher-Order Rectifiability
John Hoffman
TL;DR
The paper develops square-function characterizations of $I_\alpha(BMO)$ for $0<\alpha<2$, distinguishing between multiscale approximation by constants ($0<\alpha<1$) and by affine functions ($1\le\alpha<2$). It proves both directions: (i) $f\in I_\alpha(BMO)$ implies precise $L^2$-type square-function bounds tied to $\nu_0^f$ or $\nu_1^f$, and (ii) those square-function bounds imply $f\in I_\alpha(BMO)$, using Strichartz’s criteria, approximate Taylor tools, and a Dorronsoro-type framework. The work connects $BMO$-Sobolev spaces with geometric measure theory notions of higher-order rectifiability, and it provides rigorous foundations for the behavior and representation of distributions in $I_\alpha(BMO)$, including duality and regularity properties. The results yield a quantitative, end-point analogue of Dorronsoro's theorem and establish a concrete link between analytic square-function control and geometric approximation, with potential implications for parabolic uniform rectifiability and related areas.
Abstract
We provide new characterizations of the $BMO$-Sobolev space $I_α(BMO)$ for the range $0 < α<2$. When $0 < α<1$, our characterizations are in terms of square functions measuring multiscale approximation of constants, and when $1 \leq α<2$ our characterizations are in terms of square functions measuring multiscale approximation by linear functions.
