Densities Of Primes And Primitive Roots
N. A. Carella
TL;DR
The work analyzes primes $p$ for which a fixed integer $u$ is a primitive root modulo $p$, establishing an effective lower bound $ obreak \\\pi_u(x) \\gg \\frac{x}{\\log x}$ and clarifying the density $\\delta(u)$ of such primes. It develops divisors-free representations for the primitive-root indicator and leverages powerful exponential-sum bounds, including finite summation kernels and Gauss sums, to control error terms. The main term is linked to the Artin constant $a_1$ via sums of $\\varphi(p-1)$ and related averages, yielding unconditional positive densities and precise asymptotics for bases such as $u=10$, where $\\delta(10)=a_1 \\\approx 0.3739...$, and $\\pi_{10}(x)=\\delta(10) \\mathrm{li}(x) + O(x/\\log^B x)$. The results generalize to maximal-period decimal expansions and fixed-base counts, providing stronger density results than prior $x/\\log^2 x$ bounds and removing subset restrictions on $u$, with implications for Artin-type conjectures on primes and primitive roots. The methodology offers a versatile framework for estimating primitive-root densities via divisors-free indicators and robust exponential-sum techniques, enhancing our understanding of primitive-root distributions in the integers modulo primes.
Abstract
Let $u\neq \pm 1,v^2$ be a fixed integer, let $p\geq 2$ be a prime, and let $\text{ord}_p(u)=d \:|\: p-1$ be the order of $u \text{ mod } p$. This note provides an effective lower bound $π_u(x)=\# \{ p\leq x:\text{ord}_p(u)=p-1 \}\gg x (\log x)^{-1}$ for the number of primes $p\leq x$ with a fixed primitive root $u \text{ mod } p$ for all large numbers $x\geq 1$. The current results in the literature have the lower bound $π_u(x)=\# \{ p\leq x:\text{ord}_p(u)=p-1 \}\gg x (\log x)^{-2}$, and restrictions on the fixed primitive root to a subset of at least three or more integers. An application to repeating decimal $1/p$ of maximal period $p-1$ is included, and a precise counting function for the number of primes $p\leq x$ with a fixed primitive root $10 \text{ mod } p$ for all large numbers $x\geq 1$.
